PARIS, FRANCE On the morning of Saturday, Aug. 30, Dodi and Diana sat on the top deck of the Jonikal and admired the sparkling waters of Sardinia's Emerald Coast. Relaxed, tanned and blissfully happy, so Diana had told her friend Rosa Monckton, they chatted and basked in the sun, enjoying the last moments of their magical Mediterranean cruise.
Butler Rene Delorm arrived on deck at 9:30 with their breakfast: coffee, croissants and jam; a basket of bananas, apples, grapes, oranges and kiwis. Diana, as usual, took a large glass of fresh orange juice and poured hot milk in her coffee. Dodi skipped the juice and drank his coffee black. "It was a quiet morning. They were in a good mood," Delorm recalls. "They never stopped talking the whole cruise. It was amazing; they never ran out of things to talk about. They were always laughing, holding hands." |
"[Diana] had expressed concern to Trevor Rees-Jones at the foolhardiness of the motorcycle riders ... that the erratic manner in which they were driving might result in one of them falling under the wheels either of the lead car or the backup," said Fayed security chief Paul Handley-Greaves. Associated Press, Aug 25, 1998 |
The elder Fayed had ordered the Duke and Duchess's effects cleared out and auctioned off for charity in order to turn the property over to his family's personal use. Dodi had a plan for the stately mansion.
"Frank," he said. "Where do we stand on the Windsor Villa?"
Klein informed him that the Windsor artifacts had been removed as of the end of July and were to go on auction at Sotheby's in less than two weeks. The house stood empty. "Good," said Dodi. "I've spoken to my father about moving in. My friend" he didn't want to mention Diana's name for fear of electronic eavesdroppers "doesn't want to stay in England." Klein quickly guessed whom he was talking about. Then Dodi said, "We want to move into the villa, Frank, because we are getting married in October or November." "That's wonderful, Dodi!" said Klein. "Really wonderful. I'll be back in Paris on Monday and we'll talk about it."
Back in Paris that same afternoon, Dodi ran an important errand. Eight days earlier, he and Diana had picked out an engagement ring at the Monaco boutique of jeweler Alberto Repossi. |
|
A little before 6:30 p.m., Dodi sent Claude Roulet, second in command at the Ritz, and bodyguard Alexander ("Kes") Wingfield on foot to Repossi's boutique. True to his security fetish, Dodi insisted on being driven to Repossi's in the Mercedes 600, though it was less than a hundred yards from the Ritz. Trevor Rees-Jones accompanied him and waited in the car while Dodi went inside.
"Eight days earlier, at the Monaco boutique of Alberto Repossi, Dodi and Diana bought a $200,000 custom-designed engagement ring of yellow and white gold, with triangles of diamond clusters around a stunning emerald. | Dodi took delivery of the ring, which was from a line called Tell Me Yes, but also examined another one that had caught his fancy. He asked Repossi if he could take both rings to see which one the Princess preferred. The jewels were handed over to Roulet, with details about price and payment left to be worked out later between the shop and the Ritz management. |
Whatever Dodi may have planned, he never had time to carry it out. The ring was later found in his apartment, still in its unopened box. (It now lies in a safety-deposit box in a Swiss bank, along with several love letters from Diana to Dodi.)
The couple had planned to eat dinner that night at Chez Benoit, a trendy restaurant near the Pompidou Center. They stopped first at Dodi's apartment near the Arc de Triomphe, but the crowds of paparazzi were so great that they changed their mind and decided to return to the Ritz for dinner. Back at the hotel, the throngs of photographers and tourists were so large that the couple could not open the car door at first.
The couple had planned to eat dinner that night at Chez Benoit, a trendy restaurant near the Pompidou Center. They stopped first at Dodi's apartment near the Arc de Triomphe, but the crowds of paparazzi were so great that they changed their mind and decided to return to the Ritz for dinner. Back at the hotel, the throngs of photographers and tourists were so large that the couple could not open the car door at first. |
"Cameras were right next to her face ... Once inside, she sat on a chair and looked ... as if she were about to cry." |
DODI WAS LIVID. It was now almost 10 p.m. A night security officer named Francois Tendil called Henri Paul, acting head of security, to tell him about the chaotic scene. Paul, who had met the couple at the airport and transported their baggage to Dodi's apartment earlier in the day and had gone off duty at 7:05 p.m., rushed back. What he had been doing during his few hours off is still unclear, as is how much alcohol he might have consumed.
Dodi arranged for his regular car and driver plus a backup vehicle to leave from the front and act as decoys. He, Di and Rees-Jones would leave from the rear with Henri Paul at the wheel of the Mercedes. | What is clear is that when he got back to the hotel, he wound up in the Vendome bar, where he managed to drink right under the noses of Dodi's two English bodyguards. Wingfield told police Paul drank "pineapple juice, which he cut with water from a carafe, because he found it too strong." Rees-Jones later told police Paul had consumed a "yellow liquid." But that "yellow liquid" turned out to be pastis, an anisette-based aperitif about as strong as whiskey. |
After dinner, Dodi called his father and told him that he and the Princess would soon leave the Ritz for his apartment. Mohammed Al Fayed didn't like his plan at all.
|
"Don't go," he warned. "There's a lot of press out there, a lot of people. Why don't you just stay in the hotel?"
"We can't, Moo-Moo," said Dodi, using his nickname for his father. "We have all our things back at the apartment, and we have to leave from there in the morning." "Just be careful," said his father. "Don't step on it. There's no hurry. Wait until you see the atmosphere is perfect, get in your car, and go away. Don't hide; it is unnecessary. You have security with you. If they want to shoot you, fine, then at least we know they shot you. But to go out the back, change the driver..." But Dodi had already made up his mind. During these final moments, he seemed to get more and more excited about his plan. As Wingfield described the minutes before the departure: "[Dodi] was happy, so was the Princess. They joked and laughed."
"It might seem ironic, but I had never seen the couple of Dodi and the Princess as happy as at the moment that they were about to leave calmly from the rear of the hotel." |
COULD DIANA HAVE BEEN SAVED? By the time the Mercedes reached the stoplight in the Place de la Concorde, at least half a dozen paparazzi had caught up with it. Taking off just before the light changed, Henri Paul headed onto the riverfront expressway along the 4,000-ft. straightaway leading to the Alma tunnel.
Some 30 seconds later, Paul suddenly lost control of the car and crashed into the tunnel's 13th pillar. The Mercedes spun around 180[degrees] and came to rest against the north wall with its horn blaring from the weight of the driver's inert body on the wheel. Paul and Dodi were killed instantly. Diana and Rees-Jones were grievously injured. |
"When I saw Diana in the backseat, I got shivers up my spine," says photographer Nikola Arsov. "You can't imagine how beautiful she was. It was devastating!" |
"When I saw Diana in the backseat, I got shivers up my spine," says photographer Nikola Arsov, who had followed the decoy cars and arrived at the scene some time after the accident. "You can't imagine how beautiful she was. It was devastating!"
The driver's body is slumped over the horn. The impact is so great that parts of the radiator are reportedly found embedded in his body. Associated Press |
Photos show Diana in profile, quite recognizable with her elegantly coiffed blond hair. There is blood on her forehead; trails of blood also trickle from her nose, mouth and left ear. Apart from the blood, her face is not disfigured. Dodi's left leg, horribly bent and deformed by multiple fractures, lies on Diana's lap. Diana's left arm is draped listlessly over his kidskin boot. |
Diana was brought up from the basement operating room where she died to a room on the second-floor intensive-care corridor where French and British officials had set up their crisis center. Nurses had cleaned the body and covered her with a white sheet up to the shoulders. The sheet over the Princess's body obscured her most grievous wounds, and the blood had been wiped from her face.
But what was not apparent had been chronicled shortly before by the Paris medical official who performed an external examination on Diana's body. The report showed a 3-cm wound on the forehead, a cut over the lip, crushed ribs, a fractured right arm, an 8-cm cut on the right thigh, bruises on both hands and feet and a cut on the right buttock. The body chart did not detail the internal injuries, however, since the Princess's chest had already been sewn up by the surgeon. |
"You could see a terrible accident had happened and there were photographers, like, all over the place swarming," says tourist Robin Firestone. "And I was looking at my husband and I said, 'Is this what happens in Paris when you have an accident?'" Associated Press |
"The pulmonary vein is a large vessel that empties into the left atrium of the heart," says a thoracic surgeon at a public hospital in Paris. "It's the vessel that feeds oxygenated blood back into the heart. It is a large vein, with a heavy blood flow, which can be ripped in the case of a major shock or deceleration.
The Princess died of "internal hemorrhaging due to a major chest trauma and a phenomenon of deceleration which caused a rupture of the left pulmonary vein." Medical Examiner's report |
This produces a pulling on the vein, which can cause it to snap and rip off. That provokes a hemorrhage in the chest that is very quickly fatal. If it is really torn off, there is virtually no chance of survival. The blood empties out very quickly, with a compression of the heart, the lungs, followed by a heart attack and cardiac arrest. The person dies very quickly." |
Another French physician, the head of emergency services at a large Paris hospital, says the fact that Diana did not die immediately of a massive hemorrhage indicates that the tear in the pulmonary vein was "either a small one" or that it was partially closed, "perhaps by a bone fragment from a fractured rib." Thus it might have been possible to save her "with some luck and intelligence" if that was her only internal lesion.
These physicians are careful to point out that they do not have enough precise information about the nature and extent of Diana's injuries to come to any definitive conclusions about her case.
Freer to analyze and speculate is Dr. John Ochsner, 70, chairman emeritus of surgery at Ochsner Clinic in New Orleans and one of America's pre-eminent cardiovascular surgeons. "The reason [Diana] didn't bleed out right away is that the tear was probably clotting and because the pressure there is so modest." |
"The philosophy here is to try to stabilize the patient as much as you can, because traveling with this kind of status can be very dangerous for a patient." Dr. Frederic Mailliez, |
It took an hour and 45 minutes from the time of the accident to the time the Princess entered the operating room. What was going on during all that time? First, it took 15 minutes for the first fully equipped ambulance and its onboard doctor to reach the scene. Second, it was a slow, delicate operation to get Diana out of the car; even though the door was open, emergency workers had to cut through metal to free her because one of her legs was pinned under the seat. Third, she received extensive treatment on site, lasting between 30 and 45 minutes, before the ambulance ever rolled. Once inside the large, boxlike ambulance, which was fully equipped as a mobile hospital unit, Diana was put on an IV drip (essentially liquids and dextrose), intubated, attached to a respirator and given external cardiac stimulation.
"The philosophy here is to try to stabilize the patient as much as you can, because traveling with this kind of status can be very dangerous for a patient," said Dr. Frederic Mailliez, an experienced emergency doctor who was the first to reach the scene, before the ambulance arrived. "So we try to restore a little bit of blood pressure and some other things before we start to drive."
Similarly, says Mailliez, it is not uncommon for emergency doctors to tell ambulance drivers to go slowly. "If you are braking or accelerating," he explains, "it can be very bad for the blood pressure, so you have to be very careful." A spokeswoman for the French hospital system confirms that Diana's ambulance "slowed down and rolled gently. It's common sense."
"Stabilizing patients in the field is a mistake we made for decades in the U.S. before we abandoned it in favor of the scoop-and-run method about 10 years ago." Dr. David Wasserman, |
Ochsner takes issue with such reasoning. "You couldn't try to repair that injury on the scene; you'd have to be in the hospital," he says. The external chest massage would probably be "the worst thing that could happen," he argues. "Once you start beating on the chest, you increase pressure in all the chambers at one time." |
So could the Princess of Wales have been saved if she had reached the hospital earlier?
"I can't second-guess anybody," says Ochsner. "What I'm saying is if it was a small rent, a patient would have plenty of time. But if it's big enough where it's slowly bleeding, as hers was something between a minor tear and a complete bleed-out there had to be some resistance of flow, with a clot or something. Otherwise she would have bled out. What I'm saying is this: given that she was still alive after nearly two hours, if they'd have gotten her there in an hour, they might have saved her."
|
Ochsner's view is supported by Dr. David Wasserman, 45, an American physician with nine years' experience working in the emergency rooms of some of the country's busiest urban hospitals, including New Jersey's Hackensack Medical Center. "If they had gotten her to the operating room sooner, she would have had a far greater chance. You could never diagnose that kind of injury in the field, never. In the U.S. there'd be hell to pay in a case like this lawsuits, internal investigations. Spending all that time on on-site treatment was absolutely the wrong approach for this patient."
While not accusing any individual medical worker of professional errors in treating Diana indeed, they clearly followed standard French procedures Dr. Wasserman argues that the fault lies with the whole French approach to emergency medicine. "Stabilizing patients in the field is a mistake we made for decades in the U.S. before we abandoned it in favor of the scoop-and-run method about 10 years ago," he says.
Before that, we found we were losing more patients by messing with them in the field than by getting them to the hospital. All kinds of studies have found a major negative correlation between the time spent in the field and a patient's prognosis. |
In most cases, the only thing we do to trauma victims on site is to stabilize the spine and start an IV drip. Then we get them to the hospital fast."
A FATHER IN QUEST OF ANSWERS Mohammed Al Fayed bounds suddenly into the boardroom at Harrods. The Egyptian tycoon is dapper in his plaid shirt and Glen-plaid trousers. Although the 40-day Muslim mourning period is over, he continues to grieve for Dodi and Diana: the tie adorning his Turnbull & Asser shirt is black. It is clear that he feels as if he has lost not only a son but two children, and at a moment when such happiness for them was in the offing.
Discussing the tragedy publicly for the first time, Al Fayed says he was as surprised as anybody when Dodi and Diana fell in love. But he could see the attraction. "She had been excited to marry the future king when she was young," Al Fayed explains. "But she had no experience of life."
"She faced this maze of tradition and bureaucracy and found that this was not the life she was looking for. After her father passed on, she would sometimes come to me for advice. She wanted to live like an ordinary person. She came from the aristocracy, but she was an ordinary girl." Al Fayed believes that Diana's Saint-Tropez holiday with him, his wife and his five children opened her eyes to the possibilities of a happy family life. "Our family, she never saw anything like it in her life," he says, noting that she had an unhappy childhood amid her parents' bitter divorce. "The freedom she enjoyed, no formalities." With a laugh, he adds, "Dodi had the same sense of humor as me. For the first time, she meets somebody like me, only younger! She enjoyed our family, and Dodi was part of it. If my son is happy, I am happy. It was his choice, his problem. I want to make him completely independent, not relying on me all the time."
"You can't believe what I am fighting here," he says. "They can't get over the fact that I own Harrods. It's an Egyptian, not a Briton, who built this store, this fantasy. How can a bloody Egyptian come from another planet and do this?" |
|
"It was a very serious matter. Maybe the future king is going to have a half brother who is a 'nigger,' and Mohammed Al Fayed is going to be the stepgrandfather of the future king. This is how they think, this Establishment. Mohammed Al Fayed |
"I am a taxpayer in this country," he continues. "I have devoted 30 years of my life employing people, bringing in business, paying hundreds of millions of pounds in taxes. This is my country. You don't want to end, after you sacrifice for all this, to be humiliated in a report commissioned by a corrupt Tory government. I am fighting a crusade for the masses, for the ordinary people." |
The meeting has been a difficult one for Al Fayed. By the end, the tension in his body has become palpable. But before excusing himself to attend another appointment, he makes a vow: "I am not going to rest until I know what happened. It is not only my son. It's the mother of two boys."
Persons close to Mohammed Al Fayed with knowledge of the official investigation have warned him that a variety of problems make it as yet impossible to conclude that Diana and Dodi died in an ordinary traffic accident. They claim that the crime scene was not properly preserved; that the Mercedes was removed from the tunnel with "indecent haste"; and that initially the French police either were ignorant or lied about a collision with a second car, the mysterious Fiat Uno. They also continue to insist, though without evidence, that the postmortem on Henri Paul was botched and thus led too easily to the drunk-driver conclusion.
Serious unanswered questions, they say, include why it took medical rescuers nearly two hours to get the Princess to a hospital; why French authorities have not made available tapes from surveillance cameras outside the ministry of justice (just next to the Ritz) and along the Mercedes' route; and why the British intelligence service has failed to come forth with what they know about the crash. |
Seeking independent information on the case, Al Fayed has launched his own investigation, involving current and former members of Scotland Yard and an ex-CIA agent, led by his own security team. |
Seeking to get independent information on the case, Mohammed Al Fayed has launched his own investigation. It is headed in Britain by Harrods security chief John MacNamara, an ex-Scotland Yard inspector, and in France by Pierre Ottavioli, a former chief of the criminal brigade and now the head of a private French security firm. A retired CIA agent with links to Ottavioli's network has also been brought into this private probe. In addition, Scotland Yard has assigned one of its own inspectors, Jeffrey Rees, to serve as a liaison with the official French investigation.
A CAR CRASH OR A PLOT? Debris found near the tunnel entrance fragments of glass and a piece of a rearview mirror indicated that the Mercedes may have collided with another vehicle before losing control. Some investigators at first theorized that a motorcycle might have made contact with the Mercedes, perhaps touching the rearview mirror with a handlebar. However, any collision with a motorcycle at that speed would certainly have knocked the two-wheeled vehicle over and probably killed its driver.
Conspiracy theorists speculate that a motorcycle worked with the Fiat Uno, pursuing the Mercedes doggedly from the Place de la Concorde, forcing it to drive faster and faster as it approached the tunnel. | But there definitely was a motorcycle right behind the Mercedes, and it does not appear to have been driven by a photographer. Three witnesses, all of whom were in the eastbound lanes, described seeing a large motorcycle in the westbound lanes slow down and pass the wreck just moments after the crash. Jean-Pascal Peyret, headed west in his Saab, was passed by a single motorcyclist just seconds after hearing the final impact. |
Some conspiracy theorists have floated the idea that a motorcycle might have been working in tandem with the Fiat Uno. Its role might have been to pursue the Mercedes doggedly and aggressively from the Place de la Concorde, forcing it to drive faster and faster as it approached the Alma tunnel. But based on the available evidence it now seems likely that Diana and Dodi died in a tragic accident. Nonetheless, as with any good conspiracy theory, many of the facts surrounding the Paris crash can be arranged to fit an assassination scenario. And unless some of the key questions are answered above all the identities of the mystery motorcycle and Fiat drivers the events of Aug. 31, 1997, will continue, at least among the conspiracy-minded, to feed speculation about plots and cover-ups for the next hundred years. |
|
AFTERWORD:
One year and countless tributes later, the most intensive investigation surrounding an automobile accident may be drawing to a close. But any criminal proceedings envisioned by the prosecutor, Maude Coujard, aren't likely to begin for yet another year. And extending well into the next century will be the impending civil claims, which are already developing into a bitter shootout between Mohamed al-Fayed, the paparazzi, the bodyguards, the Ritz Hotel, Etoile Limosine, Mercedes-Benz, and each contestant's insurers.
Most believe including prosecutor Marie Coujard that the paparazzi, yet to be formally charged, will be eventually acquitted. Any penalties are likely be minor a steep fine, but no jail. | Lead investigator Judge Herve Stephan has so far reconstructed the following scenario: For reasons known only to Dodi, he, Diana and their guards departed the Ritz in a hastily-rented Mercedes S-280, despite the availability of his father's bulletproof Mercedes 500 SEL, among other cars. |
As the Mercedes sped down the Paris tunnel, closely pursued by paparazzi, it clipped a slower white Fiat Uno, which caused the Mercedes' air bags to explosively deploy, stunning and blinding the intoxicated driver Henri Paul at a critical moment. Spinning out of control, the car crashed into a tunnel pillar.
Despite an intensive 10-month search for the Uno, however, Stephan has basically given up hope of finding it. On Nov. 13, the owner of a repainted Uno, both matching the descriptions of eyewitnesses, had been detained but released when interrogators determined the car failed to match evidence from the crash.
Ten paparazzi remain under investigation for involuntary homicide and nonassistance to persons in danger. In their defense they claim the Mercedes left them far behind, giving them no role in the accident. Though only one tried to call emergency services, all claim to have assumed help was on the way.
Most witnesses, however, depict them hovering about the wreck and insulting one another while jockeying for the best shots.
Stephan is still looking for other paparazzi that may have been on the scene. It is said that he suspects the ten know more about the Uno than they admit, and that the driver might have been an associate.
To date the ten have not been formally charged and are still working, sometimes at Diana-related events.
Most believe including, it has been reported, prosecutor Coujard that some will be charged but eventually acquitted. Any penalties are likely be minor a steep fine, but no jail.
Even so, we can be assured that the trial, once begun, far beyond what was witnessed during the O.J. Simpson trial, will be the most watched event in history.
After two years of investigating a number of theories about the crash and testimony from almost 200 people, on Sep. 3 French judges completely cleared photographers as well as Dodi al Fayed of responsibility for the fatal accident. They laid the finger of blame solely on driver Henri Paul, who was inebriated and taking anti-depressants and consequently lost control of the speeding limo.
The judges determined that Paul had to avoid a slower-moving car entering the tunnel, a reference to the elusive white Fiat Uno he apparently grazed before crashing. French police never found the car despite a dragnet involving over 4,000 Fiat Uno owners. |
While imposing "a continuous and insistent presence," the photographers could not be placed at the moment of the crash. |
While it was agreed that several of the photographers had imposed "a continuous and insistent presence" on Dodi and Diana since the couple arrived in Paris, the photographers "did not resort to ruse or violence," nor was there any evidence that they were close to the Mercedes-Benz at the moment of the accident."
Besides clearing the photographers, the ruling also dismissed charges that emergency medical crews had been tardy in coming to the aid of Diana, who was not killed on the spot. "The surgical team cannot be reproached for anything, since no other surgery or reanimation strategy could have altered the patient's condition," judges said.
To Mohamed al Fayed's charges of conspiracy and murder, judges concluded "no element however imprecise has given any backing to such theses." The accident "was not the result of a deliberate act."
from Reuters, Sep 3, 1999.
LINKS
The Final Hours Time, Feb 16, 1998, vol. 151 no. 6 |
||
Excerpts from Thomas Sancton and Scott MacCleod's "Death of a Princess: The Investigation." |
||
Mystery in the Details: Time, Aug 31 1998, vol. 152 no. 9 |
||
More from Sancton and MacCleod. | ||
Piecing Together Diana's Final Hours Associated Press, Aug 26 1998 |
||
Timetable to tragedy. | ||
Princess Diana Full Coverage | ||
Just about everything but the sink. | ||
The First Diana Conspiracy Site | ||
Definitely not the official story. | ||
Diana Murdered: Says Purported CIA Document | ||
Where does this stuff come from? | ||